When it comes to book adaptations, it seems only fair that they are judged solely on the film and not in comparison to the novel it comes from.

With that in mind, “If I Stay” (Rated PG-13; 107 min) is still a terrible adaptation.

“If I Stay” is a teen drama adaptation directed by R.J. Cutler, staring Chloe Grace Moretz, Mireille Enos, and Stacy Keach.

Advertisement

Mia Hall is in an automobile accident, killing her family and putting her in a coma. She soon discovers her spirit has left her body and is confined to the hospital. Once she learns the status of her family, Mia has a decision to make. Should she stay or should she go?

This film fails on pretty much everything it tries to do. There is absolutely no chemistry between Moretz, her family and boyfriend. It is unclear whether that is because of the terrible dialogue or generic scenes this film gives or the cardboard acting some of the acts do.

One of the worst things about the film is the focus on the absence in chemistry between Mia and Adam, played by Jamie Blackley.

Cliché romantic teen drama scenes take away from Moretz’s performance.

There are a few points where the film veers off from this tired storyline. In those moments, we are given a little glance into a much better film. Keach, who plays Mia’s grandfather, gives his little role as much as he can give and even elevates it.

The movie seemed to follow an interesting plot. It was becoming an emotional teen drama focused on the family dynamic, suffering and dealing with death. Then the director said, “Wait. That was way too interesting.”

The plot of “If I stay” is a lie. A lie, perpetrated by not only the trailer for this film, but also by every website with a plot description for this movie.

Advertisement*

The plot described is one of a much more interesting film in an alternate universe. One where this film is loved just as much as a film like “The Fault in Our Stars” or “Romeo and Juliet.”

This film instead is about a girl who gets in a car accident, whose family dies, and is between death and life and must decide where to go.

But instead of reminiscing on life with her family, boyfriend, and music, she tends to focus on her boyfriend and this film becomes a “The Fault in Our Stars” copycat.

Do not see “If I Stay.” Go watch Breakfast Club for the hundredth time.

Go give “The Fault in our Stars” a chance. “Dazed and Confused” is at Family Video waiting for you.

Only see this movie if you have to or are fan of the book and want to give it a try.

Jacob Pierce can be reached at [email protected], on Twitter @Jacob Pierce1_DE or at 536-3311 ext. 273