A historic decision: Voters will choose between Lightfoot and Preckwinkle to become Chicago’s first African-American female mayor

Mayoral+candidate+Lori+Lightfoot+and+her+daughter+Vivian+Lightfoot+appear+with+supporters+Tuesday+night%2C+Feb.+26%2C+2019+at+EvolveHer+in+Chicago.
Back to Article
Back to Article

A historic decision: Voters will choose between Lightfoot and Preckwinkle to become Chicago’s first African-American female mayor

Mayoral candidate Lori Lightfoot and her daughter Vivian Lightfoot appear with supporters Tuesday night, Feb. 26, 2019 at EvolveHer in Chicago.

Mayoral candidate Lori Lightfoot and her daughter Vivian Lightfoot appear with supporters Tuesday night, Feb. 26, 2019 at EvolveHer in Chicago.

Erin Hooley/Chicago Tribune

Mayoral candidate Lori Lightfoot and her daughter Vivian Lightfoot appear with supporters Tuesday night, Feb. 26, 2019 at EvolveHer in Chicago.

Erin Hooley/Chicago Tribune

Erin Hooley/Chicago Tribune

Mayoral candidate Lori Lightfoot and her daughter Vivian Lightfoot appear with supporters Tuesday night, Feb. 26, 2019 at EvolveHer in Chicago.

By Bill Ruthhart, Gregory Pratt, and Juan Perez Jr.

Chicago voters will make history Tuesday when they head to the polls and pick either former federal prosecutor Lori Lightfoot or Cook County Board President Toni Preckwinkle to become the city’s 56th mayor.

No matter the result of the runoff election, Chicago will elect for the first time an African-American female to occupy City Hall’s fifth floor. If Lightfoot wins, Chicago also would become the largest U.S. city ever to elect an openly gay mayor.

Both candidates repeatedly have acknowledged the historic nature of the campaign since emerging as the top two vote-getters among a record field of 14 candidates in February’s first-round election.

Advertisement

“I think about the children, and the city they will grow up in and what it will mean for young boys and girls to see leaders who look like them in the mayor’s office. You know what they say, ‘You cannot be what you cannot see,’” Preckwinkle said during a rally before hundreds of African-American voters at the Harold Washington Cultural Center last month. “I hope this election tells them that no dream is too big or challenge too great. And this is truly a historic moment. Not long ago, the idea that two African-American women would be vying for this spot would have been considered impossible.”

Voters here have not elected an African-American mayor since Harold Washington won re-election in 1987 before dying in office later that year. The city also only has elected one woman as mayor, Jane Byrne, who held the office for one term from 1979 until 1983.

“We are on the eve of a historic election in our city, one of the first times we’ll have a real choice since Harold Washington ran for the second time,” Lightfoot said in a Saturday speech to a few hundred black voters at Rainbow/PUSH Coalition’s Kenwood headquarters. “We have the opportunity to bring all parts of our city together, to forge a new direction for our city that welcomes everyone to the table.”

While a five-week campaign between two African-American women to become mayor is unprecedented, the race has been defined more by the two contenders trading barbs over whether Lightfoot’s mantra of change or Preckwinkle’s argument for experience suits the city best.

“While this moment is historic, we are not indistinguishable. We took very different paths to get here,” Preckwinkle, 72, said in contrasting herself to Lightfoot, 56. “I’ve proudly served as a public servant in this city for 25 years, so I’m not afraid of big challenges or hard work. I know what it takes to tackle them, and I know how gratifying it is when our members bend the arc of history a little closer to justice, day by day.”

Lightfoot, a first-time candidate for public office, has said Chicagoans’ desire to break free from the city’s history of machine politics outweighs talk of political resumes.

“This election is historic, not merely because there are two black women vying to be the leader of our great city, but it’s historic in my view because it gives us the opportunity to create change, change that is necessary to break from the status quo, to break from the broken and corrupt political machine that has left far too many of our people behind,” Lightfoot said during her Saturday speech. “That machine that covets compliance, that covets secrecy and loyalty at the expense of everything else.”

Both candidates spent Monday scurrying around the city and encouraging voters to fulfill their civic duty amid mounting concerns about low voter turnout.

Chicago has 10 percent more registered voters now than it did in 2015 when Mayor Rahm Emanuel defeated challenger Jesus “Chuy” Garcia, thanks to an uptick in voter interest ahead of the 2018 midterm elections.

In February, 35 percent of registered voters cast ballots, up slightly from 34 percent in 2015. The difference in raw votes was larger, with 560,701 casting ballots this year compared with 483,700 in 2015.

City election officials reported that early voting ahead of Tuesday’s runoff was down slightly from five weeks ago. In the February election, 125,000 voters cast early ballots, while this time around the final number was 122,829. The final rush to vote also dropped off, with 25,703 voting early on the final Monday before the election five weeks ago compared with 17,850 this time.

Asked Monday if she would be disappointed if turnout again hovers around 35 percent, Lightfoot replied, “The only thing I’m going to be disappointed by is a loss. I think we need to keep focus and bring people out.”

Standing in front of a tomato and peppers stand outside the Devon Market in Rogers Park, Lightfoot said she has been feeling an “energy surge” around her campaign.

“What we keep hearing from people affirmatively is they want change,” she said.

Lightfoot was walking through the grocery store shaking hands and greeting potential voters when she encountered 58-year old Marcee Williams.

“I just voted. Congratulations,” said Williams, a human resources manager. “I hope you go all the way.”

“With your help, we definitely will. Appreciate it,” Lightfoot said. “Talk to anybody you know who hasn’t voted yet.”

“I’ll try. I’ll try,” Williams replied. “I just texted a few friends, ‘No lines, no waiting, at Pratt and Western, go now.’ ”

Lightfoot started the day greeting voters at the Garfield Red Line station before stopping at Everybody’s Coffee in Uptown, where she ordered a Mexican hot chocolate and blueberry muffin. She also swung by Big Top Restaurant, a Jefferson Park diner with classic game shows playing on the TV, and Superdawg in Norwood Park, where she had a Polish sausage and chocolate shake in between posing for pictures.

Lightfoot also visited a nearby fire station.

“Any questions for me?” asked Lightfoot, who has been endorsed by the firefighters union.

After a pause, one firefighter replied, “Can I get a photo?”

After Preckwinkle started the day rallying with workers alongside U.S. Rep. Danny Davis in West Garfield Park and handing boxed lunches to needy residents in Humboldt Park, she took a moment on Monday to pray.

The brief silence amid what she has described as a “brutal campaign” occurred inside a Sikh gurdwara amid Devon Avenue’s bustling South Asian and Middle Eastern community.

Preckwinkle just had eaten half a samosa and toured a segment of the avenue’s grocers, restaurants and merchants with a clutch of campaign staff and supporters.

But before her security team pressed her into an SUV to hurry off to the day’s next event, Preckwinkle followed leaders of the Devon Gurudwara Sahib up a flight of carpeted stairs. She then stood barefoot before a small altar, eyes closed, head bowed and covered in a traditional orange turban, as one of the leaders prayed in Punjabi for her success from a holy Sikh script.

“She’s worked with our community for a long time,” businessman and supporter Ashref Hashim said. “The sense people have is that she’s open to embracing the community.”

Shelia Jones, 62, a retired Chicago Public Schools worker, rushed over to introduce herself to the candidate and grab a campaign sticker when Preckwinkle’s entourage crowded through the entrance of the nearby Fresh Farms market.

“I think we need to give her a chance,” Jones said, after Preckwinkle left to visit another shop. “She’s been around a long time, and I’ve just been thinking about how much I like her values. She’s a schoolteacher, and I like her method. I like her strength. She’s a motivator. She’s a protector. She’s a leader.”

Earlier, the convoy of the Cook County Democratic Party chair rolled to the Turkey Chop eatery in Humboldt Park.

The restaurant distributes boxed lunches to residents each Monday, offering Preckwinkle an opportunity to bag food and shake hands in one of the city’s most difficult neighborhoods.

Quentin Love, Turkey Chop’s proprietor and a local philanthropist, suggested to Preckwinkle that her current post as head of the county could be seen as a more powerful position than Chicago mayor.

The candidate replied by noting she had prioritized issues such as criminal justice reform during her tenure and felt comfortable with the results of that work.

“After that, I thought I’d take on some new challenges,” Preckwinkle told Love, and then quipped: “The city sure is a challenge.”

“So and after that, after the mayor, that’s it?” Love asked. Or was she perhaps considering another office?

“No, no, no, no,” Preckwinkle said, shaking her head. “That’s it. That’s it. That’s it.”

The polls at Chicago’s 2,069 precincts are open Tuesday from 6 a.m. until 7 p.m.

Once they close, a new era in Chicago’s storied political history begins.

Advertisement